Handcrafted Carrot Cake - Made to Order

Savour the perfect balance of warmth and sweetness with our classic handmade carrot cake, crafted from scratch just for you. This beloved favorite brings together tender spiced cake studded with fresh carrots, creating a moist, flavorful dessert that feels like comfort in every bite.

Each generous cake serves 12 people with satisfyingly large slices, making it ideal for celebrations, gatherings, or any occasion that calls for something genuinely homemade. The perfectly spiced cake and luscious cream cheese frosting come from using quality ingredients and time-honored baking techniques—no shortcuts, no compromises.

What makes it special:

• Baked fresh to order—never pre-made
• Generously sized to serve 12 with hearty portions
• Perfectly spiced with cinnamon and loaded with fresh carrots
• Made completely from scratch using premium ingredients

Please note: To ensure the highest quality, we require 3 days' notice for all orders. This allows us the time to source fresh ingredients and give your cake the attention it deserves.

All cake orders will be confirmed by Riverhead Sourdough before baking. You’ll receive a confirmation email.